When people think about Key West, the things that come to mind may be a “No shoes, no shirt, no problems” “Anything Goes” attitude, palm trees, dolphins, Key Lime Pie, and Parrotheads. With a roster like that it’s easy to overlook the gourmet cuisine they’re cooking up on the island. Here are some of our favorite places for food and drink in Key West:
Captain Tony’s Saloon:
Like Sloppy Joe’s (and rumored to be the original Sloppy Joe’s), Captain Tony’s is a Key West staple. It is said to be the oldest bar in Key West. If you have been there, you know every inch of the wall and ceiling is covered with dollar bills, police patches, bras, license plates and more left behind by visitors from the past several decades! It’s a unique, laid back dive bar where you often find “pass the jar” live music that should be enjoyed with your Pirate Punch!
428 Greene Street, Key West, FL
Blue Heaven:
Blue Heaven may seem like a strange dining experience with Hemingway’s cats and Key West’s famous roosters roaming around the tables in the backyard dining area but they are regulars at this establishment and don’t seem to bother the guests. The dinners are great but the thing to go for is their mile high Key Lime Pie!!
729 Thomas Street, Key West, FL
Deuce’s “Off the Hook” Grill:
Off the Hook is a small local restaurant hidden amongst island homes (previously on Simonton Street). Fresh catch is on the menu daily and is paired with yummy, funky sides like sweet potato tater tots with maple syrup! Since we dined here, I have read that this location closed, however they plan to move their restaurant to a new location so continue checking their website because this place was worth a visit!!
www.offthehookkeywest.com
The Key Lime Pie Bakery:
The Key Lime Pie Bakery should be visited simply because this is said to be the birthplace of Key Lime Pie. They have previously been voted “Best Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys” and they serve Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie on a Stick!! What’s better on a hot Florida day?!
412 Greene Street, Key West, FL
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.:
In a converted house on a local street in Key West you will instantly feel at home in the main dining room of The Flaming Buoy, an eclectic living room with a bar and cool art. The very knowledgeable staff will provide you with a great wine list and a detailed description of the evening’s specials. This is not just another seafood restaurant in Key West, these guys clearly pour their heart and soul into the art of food. Be sure to try the broccoli cakes- it’s the owner’s grandmother’s recipe!!
1100 Packer Street, Key West, FL
Better Than Sex Desserts
There is a reason I saved this one for last…you always save the best for last. We ate here in 2010 during our first visit to Key West and it was the first reservation I made when we returned in 2018. Not only are the handmade desserts outrageous but they add a special touch with their “rimmed glasses”. Whether you are having wine or just a plain old glass of milk, you can have your glass dipped in decadent chocolate or creamy caramel to make it hit the spot just right. This is a great pick for a romantic date but I would recommend eating light or not at all before you go so you can fully enjoy all the mouthwatering goodness BTS has to offer!! Bonus: They have flourless chocolate cake for those of you have don’t get along with gluten!
926 Simonton Street, Key West, FL
Now that I have you salivating, I hope you enjoyed this post as much as I enjoyed eating my way through Key West!!
See you next time with Excursions, Activities, and Attractions in Key West!!